Beyond the Façade: Uncovering the Financial Distress of an Empire State Neighbor

Published on 2025-10-18

By Benqing Shen | LinkedIn

At first glance, One West 34th Street is just another office building in the heart of Manhattan. Located directly across from the iconic Empire State Building, it's a prime piece of real estate that thousands of people pass every day. But by digging into its financial documents, we can uncover a fascinating story of risk, reward, and the dramatic shifts in commercial real estate.

The story begins in March 2017 with a $150 million refinance. Today, with that loan maturing in 2027, the property's financial health tells a cautionary tale for the entire market.

The Picture in 2017: A Solid Bet on Paper

Back in 2017, when the $150 million interest-only loan was originated, the property was performing exceptionally well. Based on a fresh appraisal of $280 million, the deal looked like a conservative bet in a strong market.

The key metrics from the 2017 loan underwriting were all positive:

  • Occupancy: A strong and stable 95%
  • Net Operating Income (NOI): A robust $11.4 million
  • Debt Service Coverage Ratio (DSCR): A healthy 1.63x, meaning income comfortably covered the debt payments

The property's income was powered by a mix of office tenants and lucrative, high-foot-traffic retail. While there were early warning signs of weakness in the retail sector, the overall financial picture in 2017 was overwhelmingly positive.

The New Reality in 2025: A Looming Crisis

Fast forward to today, and the post-pandemic landscape has created severe headwinds for office properties. The most recent performance report from September 2025 reveals a property in deep distress.

1. The Occupancy and Rent Stagnation

The most glaring issue is the collapse in occupancy, which has plummeted from a stable 95% to just 66% today.

This high vacancy is confirmed by current broker listings, which show nearly 20 separate office spaces available for lease. More telling, the asking rents for these spaces are around $46-$47 per square foot. This is effectively stagnant compared to the average underwritten office rent of $47.55 per square foot back in 2017. After eight years of inflation, zero rent growth signals a profoundly weak market for this asset.

2. The Financial Fallout

The combination of high vacancy and stagnant rents has delivered a devastating blow to the property's bottom line.

  • The annualized Net Operating Income (NOI) has fallen to $4.63 million, a staggering 59% drop from 2017
  • Consequently, the DSCR has fallen to a critical 0.61x. A DSCR below 1.0x means the property's income is no longer sufficient to cover its mortgage payments

Despite these catastrophic metrics, servicer data shows the loan is still current and not in special servicing. This suggests the borrower may be funding the shortfalls out-of-pocket for now. But this is not sustainable; the "current" status masks the deep distress of an asset that cannot support its debt.

Putting the Distress in Context: A Data-Driven Valuation

But how does this property's distress compare to the surrounding market? And what is it really worth today? To answer these questions, we used our platform, Financialyst AI, to perform a deep analysis against a curated set of truly comparable buildings.

The data immediately reveals two critical insights.

First, the market is not the problem; this property is. While One West 34th Street struggles with 66% occupancy, its direct competitors boast a healthy average occupancy of 95.1%. This isn't a story of a sinking tide lowering all boats; it's a story of one asset significantly underperforming its peers.

Second, the income gap is massive. The performance gap is even starker on a revenue basis. The subject property generates a Net Operating Income of just $22.02 per square foot, less than half the $51.58 per square foot average of its comparable set. This demonstrates a severe operational or leasing disadvantage.

This underperformance has a direct and devastating impact on the property's value. Our AI-driven model, which weights these real-time performance metrics, calculates the property's current value at approximately $87 million.

When compared to the outstanding $150 million loan balance, the result is a staggering $63 million refinance gap. The owner would need to inject this amount in new equity to successfully refinance, or risk defaulting and losing the property.

From Data to Decisions

The story of One West 34th Street is a clear example of how high vacancy and poor performance relative to the market can create a massive financial hole, turning a once-solid asset into a deeply troubled one.

In today's market, this kind of granular, comparative analysis is no longer a luxury—it's essential for survival. Don't get caught by surprise.

Reach out to the Financialyst AI team today to get access to the full comparable data set for this property and to schedule a demo of how you can use our valuation model to stress-test your own portfolio.

← Back to Blog